Missing contemporaneous time records: how courts cut fee awards

Missing contemporaneous time records: how courts cut fee awards

Many courts require fee applicants to submit time records made at or near the time the work was done. Without them, courts reduce the award, and some courts deny fees for the undocumented time altogether.

Rulings tracked
47
Median cut for this reason
25%
Total fees cut in these rulings
$2.6M

Median of the percentage reductions courts stated for no contemporaneous records. Totals cover every reduction in those rulings.

What courts say

The Court finds that it is reasonable to reduce the requested fee award by twenty-five percent given the non-contemporaneous nature of Mr. Riley’s billing records.
Innovative Sports Management, Inc. v. Lizcano et al, N.D. California
we fail to see why it is reasonable for defendants to pay for counsel’s failure to keep detailed contemporaneous records
HICKS v. CITY OF PHILADELPHIA et al, E.D. Pennsylvania
the Court finds that a reduction of 40% of the total hours claimed by Troy Law is appropriate, if not conservative
Han v. Shang Noodle House, Inc. et al, E.D. New York
While the declaration describes these amounts as “comparable” to the amount that would be earned by working a certain number of hours, there is not an actual accounting of hours worked.
Beekeepers Mill LLC v. Welcome Mat Vacations LLC et al, M.D. Tennessee
the fees requested for Jones are GRANTED, and the fees requested for Trout, Schossberger, Kluckhohn, and Zywicki must be DENIED.
Yates v. Insure Right Insurance Agency, LLC, D. Idaho

How to keep it out of your fee petition

  • Record time the same day the work happens.
  • Keep the original records, not only a cleaned-up summary.
  • Be able to show when each entry was created.

More: what a fee declaration needs · fee cuts for bad time records

FAQ

What is no contemporaneous records in legal billing?

Many courts require fee applicants to submit time records made at or near the time the work was done. Without them, courts reduce the award, and some courts deny fees for the undocumented time altogether.

How much do courts cut attorney fees for no contemporaneous records?

When federal courts cut fees for missing contemporaneous records, the median reduction they applied was 25% (24 rulings since January 2024).

How often do courts cut fees for no contemporaneous records?

In 2.9% of federal fee rulings that cut a fee since January 2024 (60 rulings).

How do you avoid no contemporaneous records on a fee petition?

Record time the same day the work happens. Keep the original records, not only a cleaned-up summary. Be able to show when each entry was created.

Rulings that cut fees for no contemporaneous records

DateCourtCasePractice areaRequestedAwardedCutRecordkeeping reasons
Oct 15, 2026N.D. CaliforniaInnovative Sports Management, Inc. v. Lizcano et al$16,562.50$11,593.7530%Missing contemporaneous records
Sep 24, 2026E.D. PennsylvaniaHICKS v. CITY OF PHILADELPHIA et alCivil rights$290,890$132,354.9554.5%Clerical work billed as legal work, Block billing, Missing contemporaneous records
Sep 8, 2026E.D. New YorkHan v. Shang Noodle House, Inc. et alWage and hour$71,763$25,732.4164.1%Clerical work billed as legal work, Clerical work billed as legal work, Vague entries, Missing contemporaneous records
Aug 13, 2026M.D. TennesseeBeekeepers Mill LLC v. Welcome Mat Vacations LLC et alConsumer protectionNot statedNot statedSee rulingMissing contemporaneous records, Reconstructed time
Jun 22, 2026D. IdahoYates v. Insure Right Insurance Agency, LLCEmployment$37,325.50$13,282.5064.4%Missing contemporaneous records
Jun 17, 2026E.D. New YorkSt. Marys Cement U.S. LLC v. Red Rock Industries, Inc. et alCommercial$61,087.04$30,00050.9%Missing contemporaneous records, Vague entries
Jun 8, 2026N.D. CaliforniaInnovative Sports Management Inc v. Sanchez et al$12,062.50$7,840.6335%Missing contemporaneous records
Jun 2, 2026M.D. PennsylvaniaSiras v. Bah et alNot statedNot statedSee rulingBlock billing, Clerical work billed as legal work, Missing contemporaneous records
Jun 2, 2026E.D. New YorkPHH Mortgage Corporation v. Allwood et alCommercial$6,800$3,40050%Missing contemporaneous records
May 4, 2026N.D. CaliforniaStellantis Financial Services, Inc. v. WindingCommercial$44,688.74$33,516.5625%Missing contemporaneous records
Apr 1, 2026Bankr. S.D. TexasLandry, Jr v. Scroggins et alBankruptcy$24,000$15,60035%Missing contemporaneous records
Feb 17, 2026D. KansasStuart et al v. Topeka, Kansas, City of et alEmployment$915,162.50$279,852.5069.4%Block billing, Missing contemporaneous records, Clerical work billed as legal work
Feb 12, 2026E.D. New YorkDeutsche Bank National Trust Company v. Tacoaman et alCommercial$6,800$3,40050%Missing contemporaneous records
Dec 12, 2025N.D. TexasJTH Tax LLC v. Brown et alIntellectual property$93,446.58$53,545.7542.7%Missing contemporaneous records
Nov 25, 2025Bankr. S.D. OhioArlene HuffBankruptcyNot statedNot statedSee rulingMissing contemporaneous records
Oct 28, 2025E.D. New YorkJTH Tax LLC v. Kukla et alCommercialNot statedNot stated15% for recordsMissing contemporaneous records
Oct 7, 2025N.D. CaliforniaInnovative Sports Management, Inc. v. Lizcano Reyes$5,837.50$3,283.5943.8%Missing contemporaneous records
Aug 27, 2025N.D. CaliforniaMoralez v. Monterey Plaza Hotel Limited Partnership, et alDisability access$1,249,454$234,958.2781.2%Missing contemporaneous records
Jun 25, 2025E.D. MichiganBrown et al v. MGM Grand CasinoEmployment$434,130$393,6809.3%Missing contemporaneous records
Jun 6, 2025E.D. PennsylvaniaMoorehead v. SCHOOL DISTRICT OF THE CITY OF ALLENTOWN et alCivil rightsNot statedNot stated20% for recordsClerical work billed as legal work, Clerical work billed as legal work, Block billing, Vague entries, Missing contemporaneous records, Vague entries, Clerical work billed as legal work, Vague entries, Missing contemporaneous records, Clerical work billed as legal work
May 27, 2025N.D. CaliforniaQuicklogic Corporation v. Konda Technologies, Inc. et alIntellectual propertyNot statedNot statedSee rulingMissing contemporaneous records
May 15, 2025E.D. CaliforniaG & G Closed Circuit Events, LLC v. Barksdale et al$19,107.50$8,25056.8%Missing contemporaneous records, Block billing, Clerical work billed as legal work, Clerical work billed as legal work
May 9, 2025D. Puerto RicoBetancourt Colon v. Arcos Dorados Puerto Rico, LLC.Disability accessNot statedNot statedSee rulingMissing contemporaneous records
Apr 28, 2025S.D. CaliforniaCase Name in Social Security Case - UnavailableSocial Security$47,728.44$12,179.4474.5%Clerical work billed as legal work, Vague entries, Block billing, Block billing, Clerical work billed as legal work, Missing contemporaneous records
Feb 18, 2025E.D. PennsylvaniaHOVAGIMIAN et al v. HOME EXCHANGE NJ LLC et alCommercialNot statedNot statedSee rulingMissing contemporaneous records
Jan 10, 2025N.D. New YorkU.S. Bank National Association v. Chenango Place, LLC et alCommercial$88,493.30$82,479.606.8%Missing contemporaneous records
Dec 20, 2024E.D. California(PC) Doe et al v. State of California et alCivil rights$40,768.15$35,246.2513.5%Clerical work billed as legal work, Missing contemporaneous records
Dec 12, 2024W.D. New YorkPickering v. U.S. Department of Justice et alFOIA$4,439.60$1,666.6762.5%Missing contemporaneous records
Nov 26, 2024D. IdahoGerard and Heather Ann Hart Living Trust, et al. v. Legends Development Company, et al.Commercial$91,315.50$88,300.503.3%Missing contemporaneous records
Nov 14, 2024W.D. New YorkPickering v. U.S. Department of Justice et alFOIA$4,439.60$1,666.6762.5%Missing contemporaneous records
Oct 17, 2024E.D. CaliforniaHernandez v. Welcome Sacramento LLC et alDisability access$53,236.27$49,0297.9%Clerical work billed as legal work, Missing contemporaneous records, Clerical work billed as legal work
Oct 10, 2024E.D. MichiganG&G Closed-Circuit Events, LLC v. Brothers Bar & Grill, LLC et al$8,729.30$3,839.5056%Missing contemporaneous records, Vague entries
Aug 26, 2024N.D. TexasWaller v. The Salvation ArmyEmployment$155,200$99,45635.9%Vague entries, Vague entries, Missing contemporaneous records, Block billing
Aug 19, 2024E.D. New YorkAlzal Corp. v. Killer Carz, LLC et alCommercial$111,428.20$77,984.5030%Missing contemporaneous records, Missing contemporaneous records, Missing contemporaneous records, Missing contemporaneous records
Aug 6, 2024D. UtahLynch v. Leatherheads Sports GrillIntellectual property$23,410$7,50068%Missing contemporaneous records
Jul 9, 2024E.D. New YorkA.H., an infant under the age of 18 years by his Mother and Natural Guardian, JOAN ASLARONA v. The Board of Education of The City of New York et alCivil rightsNot statedNot stated30% for recordsMissing contemporaneous records
May 28, 2024D. MassachusettsChristopher Drennen v. Fresenius Medical Care Holdings, Inc.,Not statedNot stated10% for recordsBlock billing, Vague entries, Missing contemporaneous records, Clerical work billed as legal work
Apr 30, 2024E.D. CaliforniaEarly et al v. Keystone Restaurant Group, LLC et alEmployment$630,387$346,192.5045.1%Vague entries, Missing contemporaneous records, Reconstructed time
Apr 15, 2024N.D. CaliforniaSilicon Genesis Corporation v. EV Group E.Thallner GmbHCommercialNot statedNot stated25% for recordsMissing contemporaneous records, Vague entries
Mar 18, 2024S.D. CaliforniaG & G Closed Circuit Events, LLC v. Finch et al$3,946.30$1,05073.4%Missing contemporaneous records, Clerical work billed as legal work
Mar 8, 2024E.D. New YorkFreedom Mortgage Corporation v. Rich et alCommercial$5,650$3,65035.4%Missing contemporaneous records
Mar 8, 2024Bankr. E.D. CaliforniaBuettner, III et al v. Residential Funding Corporation et alBankruptcy$59,475$47,58020%Missing contemporaneous records, Reconstructed time
Feb 20, 2024E.D. New YorkHenni v. Rotana Cafe & Restaurant Inc. et alWage and hour$5,250$2,00061.9%Missing contemporaneous records, Reconstructed time
Feb 16, 2024E.D. New YorkJane Doe v. Golden Krust Caribbean Bakery & Grill Inc. et alEmployment$32,670$13,82457.7%Missing contemporaneous records, Clerical work billed as legal work
Jan 18, 2024N.D. TexasGilman v. Shellpoint Mortgage ServicingCommercial$39,946.50$31,946.5020%Missing contemporaneous records
Jan 17, 2024W.D. MissouriCarson v. Citadel Federal Solutions, LLCConsumer protection$43,285$24,48043.4%Missing contemporaneous records
Jan 3, 2024W.D. PennsylvaniaDAVISON DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT, INC. v. SCORZACommercial$49,619.73$17,837.8364.1%Missing contemporaneous records

Spot an error? Email team@legaltime.ai with the case name and we will correct it. Summaries of public court opinions. Not legal advice.